An interview with David Holzer, author of Lou Reed: Metal Machine Mystic (London: Jawbone Press, 2026)

OH: I’d like to begin not with a question but a confession: when it comes to MMM, I don’t belong to either of the two opposed camps—those who dismiss it as a stupid middle finger that Lou Reed gave to the music business or those who revere it as a unique masterpiece; I belong to the third camp—those who don’t know because they never listened to it. I see your wonderful book as missionary work, trying to reach and convert the unbelievers. Am I right in thinking that it’s as much for those like me as it is for the aficionados?
DH: I am trying to reach unbelievers for sure but “convert” is too strong a word. It’s more that I’d like to open their ears even if only for a little while. To this day, Metal Machine Music is dismissed in the laziest of ways. But it’s a significant work of art, so if someone cares about rock and roll, music and the avant garde, I believe they should give it a listen, even if only for 10 seconds. I would feel my book has done part of its job if I’ve made a reader curious enough to do that. Then if they still want to dismiss it, at least they’ve given it a chance. But my book is about more than just MMM. It’s using the piece as a grimy prism through which to view Lou Reed and reveal previously hidden aspects of who he was as an artist and persona—I wouldn’t presume to suggest I have any insight into who he really was. And I’m asking the reader to take him seriously as well.
OH: Well, I would definitely agree you succeed with that—with making a persuasive case for taking Lou Reed seriously. The primary research for your book and the number of angles you cover is quite phenomenal—from an explanation of “ostrich tuning” to the spirituality of Alice Bailey, from Reed’s ECT experiences to the vibe of New York in the mid-1970s, the aesthetic of amphetamines, a brilliant close reading of the album’s liner notes, discussions of Andy Warhol and La Monte Young, and much, much more. Throughout, you also reflect on the process of your research as you go along, like a narrator, observing the dead-ends, the breakthroughs, tracking down key witnesses, and so on. Can you say something about how the book performs the path you took to get there?
DH: A reviewer compared the structure of the book to a true crime podcast in that I interview key witnesses in the attempt to build a case for MMM’s seriousness. By the end of the book, I’ve proved beyond doubt (at least, to me) that it is a serious piece of work despite it being deliberately provocative and Lou bending the truth about it for years. But my thesis—that MMM channels electricity in the form of feedback as a manifestation of the healing cosmic energy that animated Lou’s religion rock and roll, and the Tai Chi he practiced for almost half his life—isn’t actually proven by my witnesses. The book is a swirling series of facts, insights and opinions with an absence at its centre but with a thesis that runs through it all without tying it all together. I find this aesthetically pleasing and hope my readers do. Writing this answer, I realise with a shock that what I learned from studying Citizen Kane 40 years ago has never left me!

OH: Mmmmm… Kane…. Rosebud…. I like that way to describe your pursuit of the elusive secret! Just as impressive as the research backstory is how nicely it ticks along. That’s partly because of your lively music journalist prose style and partly because of the way you break up the book into bite size sections. Did the form evolve organically, or did you need to plan how to square the circle of such a deeply researched book that needed to be an uplifting read?
DH: I began with what Lou said about MMM, that the listener could start anyplace they wanted. I wanted anyone reading my book to feel the same, although the finished thing did end up being more linear than I anticipated. As for my prose style and the “bite size sections,” I’m a former advertising copywriter and journalist so I’ve learned how to keep the reader’s attention by constantly surprising them. For example, I won’t say which, but one chapter is completely invented and designed to make the reader question what they’re reading. Again, this kind of mirrors MMM. Even if you’ve listened to the piece thousands of times—as I have—you still don’t know what’s coming next.
OH: I really get that, the value of a certain game being played in your structure, its relevance to your approach. I don’t mean to take any credit for it (you already generously tip your hat in the book to the influence of my Secret of Fascination), but your approach reminds me very much of my One Shot, which on the surface is my obsessive enquiry into a single photograph, and yet really is about the personal meaning of that obsession. To some degree, I was faking it or at least projecting onto the photo a different importance to the one it really has. Whereas at the end of your book, you come out very explicitly with the deeply personal importance of MMM to you, revealing that it was literally a lifesaver, and finding in it a hidden purpose that is spiritual. It makes writing your book not just a fan’s tour de force tribute to Lou Reed, or even a vehicle to understand yourself by understanding your obsession, but, as you put it, a way to become “a better man.” Do you think it is MMM itself that works its magic, channelling Reed’s own spiritual mission, or is the vinyl more a medium, a portal, a gateway drug to finding ways to live better?
DH: First, thank you for the kind words. To answer the last part of your question first, listen to MMM at a lowish volume and it becomes like an ambient or new age piece. Something that—bizarre as this may seem—works in the same way as listening to waves lapping or whales singing or Tibetan monks chanting “Om.” I’m sure that if you established the frequencies MMM uses, they would be perfect to put your brain into an alpha or theta state (the principle on which the Dreamachine works). I have no idea whether Lou did this deliberately because of his spiritual mission. In the interviews he gave around the time of its release, he played up its power as a form of sonic terrorism. As to whether it’s a portal to “finding ways to live better,” it certainly has been for me, and I would love to think it could be for others, in the same way that any great work of art can, but that’s down to the circumstances of the listener.

And you’re absolutely right that my book is a tribute. It was born out of a love of and fascination with Lou Reed’s work and the man himself that I’ve had since I was 11 years old as well as, and this is no exaggeration, confronting my fear of MMM. It wasn’t a commission or academic exercise. It was always going to be deeply personal. I do project meaning onto the piece by recording my response when I meditate to it but it’s impossible to say what MMM means. Still, I was taken by surprise that I ended up being so impressed by it. This is why I really wanted to leave readers with a sense that Metal Machine Music is extraordinary, one of the greatest achievements in rock and roll; that Lou at his best was a remarkable artist and that, despite his obvious failings, the man had a battered nobility.
Lou Reed: Metal Machine Mystic is published in the UK on November 19. It will come out in the US in early March 2027. Order from your local bookshop or online.
